SteveH wrote:If you are on a motorway, overtaking someone who is slower but decides to speed up to the same speed as you- what do you do? Stay right next to the other one in the middle or outside lane? Hope not...
Slow down? That would be more dangerous then getting past the other one breaking the limit to get into the safer position of the inside lane.
SteveH wrote:If you are on a motorway, overtaking someone who is slower but decides to speed up to the same speed as you- what do you do? Stay right next to the other one in the middle or outside lane? Hope not...
Slow down? That would be more dangerous then getting past the other one breaking the limit to get into the safer position of the inside lane.
swatchways wrote:SteveH wrote:If you are on a motorway, overtaking someone who is slower but decides to speed up to the same speed as you- what do you do? Stay right next to the other one in the middle or outside lane? Hope not...
Slow down? That would be more dangerous then getting past the other one breaking the limit to get into the safer position of the inside lane.
Um, I'm not quite sure I understand your last point. Why would it necessarily be more dangerous to slow down and slot back behind said vehicle that decided to speed up?
gannet wrote:swatchways wrote:Um, I'm not quite sure I understand your last point. Why would it necessarily be more dangerous to slow down and slot back behind said vehicle that decided to speed up?
Following cars in your lane won't be expecting you to slow down, they will be expecting you to complete the overtake...
nigelc wrote:Example occured yesterday...I had no intention of breaking the speed limit until circumstances changed but considered it the safest option at the time.
jc2012 wrote:Assuming you're not a lorry driver, is it really necessary to pull out to overtake a vehicle if the speed differential is slow small it's going to take half an hour to get past?
jc2012 wrote:Assuming you're not a lorry driver, is it really necessary to pull out to overtake a vehicle if the speed differential is slow small it's going to take half an hour to get past?
jc2012 wrote:Turned out to be quite a long debate this one...
However, in summary, the question was "are you allowed to exceed the speed limit when overtaking". The simple answer to this by popular consensus and supported by the law is "no, you're not".
It seems that in light of this, people's personal opinions place them in one of three categories on this topic:
1) Those who think the law is the law, and won't deliberately break the speed limit under any circumstances
2) Those who don't intend to break the speed limit but will do so if they get caught out and it's the safest way of correcting the situation
3) Those who set out with the willingness to exceed the speed limit where they judge its safe to do so
Perhaps 2 demonstrates the most rounded point of view and a sensible compromise. I tend to lie somewhere between 1 and 2. I agree whole heartedly with the principle of 1, but in reality, am human and through personal error may drift into category 2 on occasions.
I strongly believe that the opinion of those in category 3 is wholly unacceptable. Such people shouldn't consider themselves to be advanced drivers....
jc2012 wrote:I strongly believe that the opinion of those in category 3 is wholly unacceptable. Such people shouldn't consider themselves to be advanced drivers if they cannot yet accept the law and at least set out with the intention of obeying it. They fall short of the requirements even to pass the basic "L" test.
jc2012 wrote:They fall short of the requirements even to pass the basic "L" test.
GJD wrote:jc2012 wrote:They fall short of the requirements even to pass the basic "L" test.
That's nonsense. I don't remember anything in my 'L' test, RoSPA test or IAM test where I was assessed on my attitude to the law, only on my ability to adhere to the law should I choose to do so. The roads are full of drivers who have passed their basic 'L' test and constantly demonstrate their willingness to break all sorts of regulations.
Return to Advanced Driving Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests